An evaluation of online practicum courses for pre-service English language teachers: Expectations, attitudes and learning


Creative Commons License

Öğr. Gör. Dr. İLKNUR KAZAZ

Tez Türü: Doktora

Tezin Yürütüldüğü Kurum: Hacettepe Üniversitesi, Eğitim Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Yabancı Diller Eğitimi A.B.D., Türkiye

Tez Danışmanı: Nuray Alagözlü

Tezin Onay Tarihi: 2022

Tezin Dili: İngilizce

Açık Arşiv Koleksiyonu: AVESİS Açık Erişim Koleksiyonu

Desteklendiği Program: Diğer

Özet:

Pre-service teacher training, preparation and development has a prominent place in the list of government’s educational agenda and is prioritized with the aim of inducing a qualified instruction in Turkish schools, and training teachers within the country. As the result of socio-economic problems in education system, educational tensions and misconceptions, many problems are encountered in pre-service teachers’ training and this is especially visible in teaching practicum which decreases the effectiveness of prospective teachers in turn. The problems in education increased more with the Covid-19 Pandemic and online teaching practicum. Feeling the need for the healing of the teaching practicum program, the researcher conducted an experimental study with a mixed method design and proposed a sample theoretical framework based on Kirkpatrick Training Evaluation Model to be implemented in Turkey. Specifically, the aim of the study is to evaluate online practicum from all stakeholders point of view. There are four research questions in this study. The first research question interrogates what the expectations of pre-service EFL teachers from Online Teaching Practicum are. The second research question interrogates what the reactions of pre-service EFL teachers to the Online Teaching Practicum are and with a sub-dimension tries to underline what the problems that pre-service EFL teachers of English encountered in Online Teaching Practicum were. The third research question tries to measure what kind of skills and knowledge have been acquired by the pre-service teachers at the end of the Online Teaching Practicum. And the last research question analyzes how Online Teaching Practicum is evaluated from pre-service EFL teachers’, mentor teachers’, university supervisors’  and administrators’ point of view. Therefore, the study used both quantitative and qualitative data analysis in order to seek answers to the research questions. A total of 370 participants were included in each phase of the study. Senior level ELT students who were taking the School Experience course at 2019-2020 academic year around various universities from every region of Turkey were questionnaired, Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) and Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) were conducted and Expectation and Reaction scales were developed with SPSS 24 and AMOS 19. Cronbach’s alpha coefficients were calculated as .96 and .98 for the expectation and reaction scales respectively. In line with the applications and analyzes, scales were found to be valid and reliable in terms of psychometry. After the scales were developed, the study was conducted with the senior students taking the “School Experience” course at state and private Universities English Language Teaching Department in Ankara in 2020-2021 school year. Pre-practicum expectation scale, post-practicum reaction Scale, self-evaluation, peer evaluation, and end-of-term evaluation statistics in relation to online teaching practicum, and interviews with the cooperating teachers, school administrators and academicians were used by the researcher to administer the experimental study. Regression, Correlation and T-test analyses were used to measure at what levels expectations were met and what were the reactions. Phenomenology analysis was conducted over the ideas coming from the interviews with mentor teachers, administrators, academicians and also participant pre-service teachers. Working groups were determined based on maximum diversity sampling method. Reflection logs,  evaluation reports and questionnaires provided by the teacher candidates added up to the qualitative dimension of the data as well. Out of the quantitative data it was concluded that online practicum failed to meet the expectations of pre-service EFL teachers. With more practice time the pre-service teachers can develop themselves professionally. Via peer-evaluation and self-evaluation based on EPOSTL which is specifically designed for and used in this study, pre-service teachers can benefit in learning. Out of the qualitative data it was once again confirmed that the technical infrastructure is limited  and students do not have the necessary equipment for online education. Economic status,  crowded and noisy houses prevent students from having a peaceful learning atmosphere. Digital materials are not enough. Coursebooks should have more i-tools to be able to be used by teachers. Video-recording should be permitted both for students and candidate teachers, therefore they could watch the lessons afterwards to make revisions and repetitions. There should be more audit and sanctions for mentor teachers to let the teacher candidates practice or observe on equal conditions. Manuals should be prepared and given to all stakeholders before the practicum. As the end-product of the study  “School Experience and Teaching Practicum Guidebook” was prepared by the researcher. Furthermore, a report called “Teaching Practicum  Report” which sheds light onto the current problems and necessary changes was written by the researcher. On request, they can be shared with the Ministry of Education or Education Faculties.

 

Keywords: online teaching practicum, teacher training, pre-service teachers, scale development, program evaluation.